|
January 2006 Marketimer Model Update
Bob Brinker Fan Club
(home Page)
by Kirk
Kirk's Update on Bob Brinker's “Five Root Causes for a Bear Market”
January, 2006 Continued
If you
want updates on what Brinker is saying on Moneytalk delivered to your email box, usually within 24 hours after
Sunday's show, then send us a note at TalkAboutMoney@gmail.com and ask to get on our mailing list.
|
In Bob Brinker’s January 2000
Marketimer newsletter he published his “Five Root Causes for a Bear
Market.”
They are:
- Tight Money:
- Rising Rates:
- High Inflation:
- Rapid Growth:
- Over Valuation:
In January 2000, he took 60% out
of the market because:
- Tight Money:He said the
Fed was reducing M2 to slow growth - BEARISH
- Rising Rates:He was predicting higher long and short
term rates to continue. This did not happen but it was – BEARISH for his model..
- High Inflation:He said the CPI was approaching 3%
and import prices were up 5% which would further impact inflation. We
didn’t get high inflation, but this was BEARISH
for his model none the less.
- Rapid Growth:Real GDP growth was approaching 5%. Bob
felt the FED would use rates to try and slow this. This was BEARISH and correct.
- Over Valuation: “We believe valuation levels in the
U.S. market are stretched to the limit.” BEARISH
All 5 of his root causes were BEARISH. On the
radio program he said he was not bearish but the odds favored a decline
over the market going up more than 5%. As such, he recommended reducing
equity allocation from 100% to 40% in his model portfolio numbers one
and two. He also lowered his P3 equity allocation from 50% to 20%.
In
the Summer of 2000 when the market was a bit higher, he recommended
taking another 5% out. Then in October 2000 he recommended
putting 20 to 50% of cash reserves back into the market via the
NASDAQ100 (QQQ) for a counter trend rally despite saying his model
had not given a buy signal. The QQQQ trade was a disaster, but his long
term model was correct to predict further weakness because 2001 and
2002 were both down years for the markets.
The market bottomed in October
2002 and his model correctly gave him a bullish buy signal within 5% of
that bottom in early 2003.
Now let’s look at the 5 root
causes today: (continued below)
|
Brinker Portfolio Return Info
Back to Bob Brinker Fan Club Home Page
Back to Bob Brinker Summaries
Click for a free issue of Kirk’s newsletter
Secular vs Cyclical Market Analysis:
"Focusing on distorted indexes is like wearing dirty classes to an IMAX movie because it clouds the details."
Other Investment Gurus
Other investment gurus to keep an eye on.
“Five Root Causes for a Bear Market” Last Updated:
April 18, 2005 HERE
|
If you
want updates on what Brinker is saying on Moneytalk delivered to your email box, usually within 24 hours after
Sunday's show, then send us a note at TalkAboutMoney@gmail.com and ask to get on our mailing list.
|
Now let’s look at the 5 root
causes today:
-
Tight Money: Long term interest rates are still near
historic lows This chart shows is up off its lows, but it remains half
what it was in the late 1980’s.
[graph that was emailed to members on the Fan Club Mailing List]
You can also see the large spike in 2000 lines up well
with the start of the bear market in the S&P500 as people were
selling bonds to buy stocks. Today it is the reverse; people are buying
safe US Treasuries rather than stocks. BULLISH
- Rising Rates:: Bob and I seem in agreement that the
Fed is only normalizing rates. This means they are going up but
it really doesn’t count because they are going up to where they should
be if we had not had a 9/11 attack AND a major recession. NEUTRAL
I also believe this will turn bullish because the Fed
should stop rising rates given the low 1.1% GDP growth announced Friday
January 27, 2006 and several months of data suggesting the housing
speculation has ended. Others, like Ed Yardeni, think the Fed will
raise rates to 5% this year. I would say this would be bearish if
short-term rates, now at 4.25%, are raised above 4.5%
- High Inflation: As long as there is an internet
connecting China and India to the US, I do not see wages being in
danger of high inflation. Higher energy prices has led to slightly
above target core inflation but the deflationary forces are secular in
nature and should help to contain core inflation. If energy prices
remain high, they could actually lead to lower inflation in future
quarters as we become even more efficient at converting energy dollars
in to GDP dollars. BULLISH
- Rapid Growth: With fourth Quarter GDP growth at
1.1%, people now are worried we will fall into a recession if the
Federal Reserve continues to raise rates. This 1/27/06 report from the US Department of Commerce
shows Q4 2005 was the lowest quarter of GDP growth since the last
quarter of 2002. ECRI’s WLI is moving higher which says we should see a
bit more GDP growth in future quarters, but no huge growth and no
recession. This is all VERY BULLISH.
- Over Valuation: I wrote in my most recent newsletter
: “For 2006, S&P estimates ‘as reported top down
earnings’ (that include options expensing) will be $82.87 (12/16/05 was
$82.87) for a forward PE of 15.1, very reasonable. I don't think we
have anything to worry about unless these pass 18 or 20 as long as long
term interest rates give an earnings yield in excess of 20. BULLISH
I have 4 at bullish and 1 at
neutral which tells me Bob Brinker will not be predicting a bear market
in the weeks ahead.
If you
want updates on what Brinker is saying on Moneytalk delivered to your email box, usually within 24 hours after
Sunday's show, then send us a note at TalkAboutMoney@gmail.com and ask to get on our mailing list.
So, what do you think?
DO you
agree with my interpretation of Bob's 5 Root Causes of a Bear Market? Send me an email with your feedback.
Since beating the market is hard
for most to do, I recommend a "Core and Explore" approach to
investing. Core means place 80 to 99% of your money into a CORE,
buy-and-hold, no load, mutual fund portfolio and then EXPLORE with the
remainder. To build your core portfolio, I suggest a
diversified basket of index funds such as one of the two Vanguard index
fund core portfolios I recommend in my newsletter. For the remainder, I
recommend Kirk's
Newsletter Explore Portfolio.
Through Jan 1, 2006, these two
core portfolios, aggressive and conservative, composed of seven
different Vanguard Index funds, have beaten the S&P500 over the
past five and seven years by over 20% using no market timing and only
rebalancing once a year. These index fund portfolios include US
equities, international equities and an REIT index fund.
As of 12/31/05 the Total Return
for "Kirk's
Newsletter Explore Portfolio" since 12/31/98 is Up
197% while the S&P500 only up 12%!!!
& NASDAQ only up 1%!!!
(My explore portfolio beta is about 1.5)
For followers of Bob Brinker, I
recommend my
newsletter core portfolio as an ALTERNATIVE to the QQQQs that Bob
Brinker recommends for his three model portfolios. The data here
shows followers of Bob Brinker would TURBO CHARGE
their returns had they replaced his recommended
QQQQ exchange traded fund with the securities in my newsletter
portfolio.
FREE Chat while
listening to Moneytalk:
http://www.suite101.com/discussion.cfm/investing/16375/900-902#message_3
==>
Drop
in
anytime for friendly chat while the Moneytalk is on. If your favorite
radio station is covering
sports and you want to hear "Moneytalk" on the internet, then drop in.
Ask our regulars in chat to
give you a link to listen to Moneytalk for free on the
internet!
Kirk Lindstrom ====>
Click for a Free Sample of my Newsletter
Editor: Investing
and Personal Finance @ Suite101.com
Click for Kirk’s: Reading
List, Financial Links, Investment
Guru Links
Kirk's Internet
Tips, Tricks & Hacks, Semiconductor
Resource Page
Bookmark my new page: World
Market Graphs & Country Information
|
DISCLAIMER: This material is neither sanctioned by, nor written under the
auspices of ABC Radio Networks, Moneytalk or Bob Brinker. This material
is not a substitute for listening to Moneytalk, it is only our
interpretation and commentary of some of what is discussed on
Moneytalk, along with additional educational information that we
include, editorial comments about the market and helpful financial
links. If you want to know what was said verbatim on Moneytalk, listen
to the show live or subscribe to "Moneytalk on Demand" which allows you
to listen to the show in case you missed it live. The web site,
bobbrinker.com has all the links to the ABC Radio Network stations that
broadcast the show live.
If you
want updates on what Brinker is saying on Moneytalk delivered to your email box, usually within 24 hours after
Sunday's show, then send us a note at TalkAboutMoney@gmail.com and ask to get on our mailing list. |
More Info:
|