Home Up Travel Links My Guidebook Travel Tips Newsletters Classes Editorials Appearances & Media My Travel Humor About Bob & Contact Custom Classes

Which web site gives the best hotel prices?

 

The challenge: Which web site should be used to shop for hotels for travel within the US?  Where do you quickly and easily find the lowest prices?  I took some of my hotel stays in the US and compared prices for trips over the next few months.  I included AAA, AARP as well as corporate discounts, and priced a room for one or two people for trips of one to seven nights.  If you really don't care about the specifics of your hotel, give Priceline or Hotwire a try.  There are very helpful message boards that are a "must read" before bidding, so visit Bidding For Travel and BetterBidding first.


Bottom line:
  Use Kayak and Travelaxe Pro in combination.  Both Kayak and Travelaxe Pro have excellent user interfaces with lots of filters to make searching easier.  They sweep other sites for prices and then take you to the site with the lowest price.  Kayak has the ability to remember your prior searches (if you login) so hotels that you examined or reserved before are listed first.  Even if you know where you want to stay, it pays to shop around because the hotel's web site provided the lowest price in only 60% of the inquiries.

 

Kayak and Travelaxe Pro rarely take you directly to the hotel company's web site to make the reservation.  So be prepared to forfeit your frequent guest credits unless you want to do extra shopping or pay more.  This is because most hotels give frequent guest credit only when you make reservation directly on their web site.  Never the less, present your frequent guest card when you check-in, it may increase the chances of a room upgrade.  For domestic airfare searches, Kayak usually takes you directly to the airline's web site (something you want to do in almost all air travel situations).
 

Travelaxe Pro is a program that you download to your PC (no Mac version).  It updates itself when necessary and does not include any "spyware" or malicious code.  The only "downside" is that it takes a few minutes to complete a search because it depends upon other web sites for prices.  Some of those sites can be slow to respond and until all sites have returned results, the lowest price may not have been found.  A few of the sites searched by Travelaxe Pro do not have "real time" prices so you may find that a rate is no longer available.  When that happens, go back and select the next lower price and try again.

Join their frequent guest programs: Although I don't usually stay in the same family or chain of hotels, by joining frequent guest programs, I've been upgraded many times.  It's worth the time and effort.

If you are looking for advice about which hotel is best for your trip, I suggest the forums at TripAdvisor and Fodors.  There have been articles written that suggest some reviews have been authored by hotel employees.  I suggest that you check both sites for the most complete story.

Tips to save more: If the hotel that you prefer is priced too high, you may find a cheaper hotel near-by.  The mapping feature of these sites can be very helpful in finding something next door or across the street.

Full payment for your reservation is often required to get the lowest prices.  Severe cancellation penalties and charges for changing a reservation are the norm for the lowest prices.  If your hotel allows you to easily cancel your reservation, it may be worth checking at least once a week to see if the price has dropped.  If it has dropped, cancel and re-book at the lower price.

When calling reservation centers, you MUST ask for their lowest available price, not just AAA or AARP.

Resort charges may be buried in the reservation at "resort" hotels or properties.  You may discover them only when you check out.  I strongly object to resort charges because they are usually "mandatory" but not included in the results during initial inquiry and comparison.  If there is any doubt about them, call the hotel before you make a reservation and inquire.  Ask about resort charges when you check in.  When I encounter them, I speak to the agent or the manager and ask them to be removed.

How to get a hotel room when they're all booked:  Trying to leave Chicago O'Hare, it was 4:30 PM and snowing heavily.  The airport was closing; very few flights were getting in or out.  I called our corporate travel department and asked them to find a hotel room for me.  There was nothing available within 20 miles!  I remembered that most non-guaranteed room reservations are canceled at 6:00 PM.  I went to the luggage area and viewed the board that displays all of the local hotels.  I started calling the hotels (using my cell phone because the attached phones were in use) and asked how many non-guaranteed reservations they had.  The first hotel I called was on the airport property and while they were officially full, they had more than enough non-guaranteed rooms to assure a room for me.

How to get a good hotel rate when you're stuck due to weather:  Very few airlines will pay for hotels unless you have elite status or unusual circumstances.  Most "walk-up" hotel rates are near the maximum even if you try AAA or AARP.  However, if you use the words "distressed passenger rate" and are kind/courteous at the check-in counter, you may get a lower rate.  That translates to "take pity on me, please."  Don't try this if it's 80 degrees and sunny.

Hotel's lowest rate guarantees: many hotels are claiming that the lowest prices are available on their web site or through their reservation centers rather then via various other web sites.  The fine print often stipulates that group discounts (AAA, AARP, etc.) can not be considered in the low rate guarantee.  I find that this exclusion makes the guarantee worthless.

$20 or free upgrade at Las Vegas hotels: For $20, you may receive a room upgrade.  Check the results from others and learn how it works at http://www.TheTwentyDollarTrick.com/.  Have you ever called a Las Vegas hotel and been asked "what brings you to Las Vegas?"  This is the time to mention your anniversary, birthday or other special celebration.  When you check in, the agent will look at the notes taken during your earlier phone call and may offer a no-cost upgrade.

Want to delay your check out?  Many hotels will allow you to delay your room departure without charge if you ask.  Call or visit the front desk as early in the day because they may be able to accommodate only a few guests.  It helps if you are a member of their frequent guest program.

Hotels have reduced the number of rooms that they sell at a discount to other web sites and consolidators.  This poses real challenges for these sites; their best option is to promote packages of airfare and hotel to mask the individual component prices.

Credit was given (in red text) for a web site if it had the lowest of price (or close) without visiting the hotel's web site.

Hotel Property Hotel web site Expedia Kayak Orbitz Travelaxe Travelaxe Pro Travelocity
Date Web site Web site Web site
Probability of getting the lowest price 60% 0% 50% 10% 30% 60% 10%
% the site could find the hotel and had rooms available   80% 90% 70% 70% 80% 100%
Courtyard Inn, Wilmington, DE 372 387 372 NA 387 372 497
5/11-5/13 Marriott Hotels WorldRes
Fairfield Inn, Greenville, SC (airport) NA 955 NA 752 955 532 946
5/10-5/17   Hotels WorldRes
Holiday Inn Express, Lake Buena Vista, Orlando, FL 701 NA 750 750 701 701 701
5/10-5/17 Orbitz InterContinental Hotels InterContinental Hotels
Caesar's Las Vegas, NV 392 405 403 403 390 390 405
5/13-5/15 Orbitz HotelClub HotelClub
Hampton Inn-Airport Richmond, Sandston, VA NA 232 196 NA NA NA 232
5/13-5/15 Orbitz    
The River Inn, Washington, DC 1,659 NA 1,858 1,979 NA NA 1,858
5/3-5/10 HotelBook
Hyatt, Dearborn, MI 204 208 186 215 NA 211 208
5/5 Skoosh   Lodging
Ritz Carlton, Phoenix, AZ 716 742 1,280 715 1,280 715 739
5/9-5/11 Skoosh Skoosh WorldRes
Comfort Inn Central Park West, New York, NY 599 685 598 NA 682 682 685
5/9-5/11 ComfortInn Lodging Lodging
Omni, San Francisco, CA 552 597 505 536 505 505 633
5/9-5/11 Skoosh Skoosh Skoosh
Hotel Property Hotel web site Expedia Kayak Orbitz Travelaxe Travelaxe Pro Travelocity
Date Web site Web site Web site

Test was conducted March 24, 2008.  Minor price differences may be the result of different methods of calculating the numerous taxes.